Estimator forensics for the wide-binary gravity test: the eccentricity-triple coupling manufactures a pseudo-signal, and a pre-registered protocol for Gaia DR4

Abstract

Analyses of Gaia DR3 wide binaries reach opposite verdicts on a claimed low-acceleration anomaly: gamma = Geff/G ~ 1.4 (Chae 2023-2026; Hernandez et al. 2024) versus Newtonian at high significance (Banik et al. 2024; Pittordis et al. 2025), from the same catalogue. We localize the disagreement experimentally. A generative model -- Keplerian binaries plus hierarchical triples with photocentre and time-averaging effects -- is validated without tuning against Pittordis et al. (2025). Synthetic cata…