Common Envelope Evolution: Too stochastic to be deterministic

Abstract

I argue for significant stochastic behavior in the common envelope evolution (CEE) of cool giants and main-sequence companions to the degree that it is almost impossible to know the exact CEE outcome of an individual binary system from the average properties of the stars and their initial orbit. I start with two observational properties of post-CEE planetary nebulae: many have jet-shaped morphologies, and they show a wide variety of morphologies. The first suggests that the standard CEE model sh…